Marcus Sheridan Didn't Plan a Marketing System. He Just Answered the Question in Front of Him.

James Clear has a line in Atomic Habits that's already sitting in my own Marketing for Photographers course, and it's worth repeating on its own: "You do not rise to the level of your goals. You fall to the level of your systems." Most business owners read that as a productivity tip. It's actually a claim about where results come from, and it says something uncomfortable: the plan isn't what produces the outcome. The habit is. The plan just tells you where you'd like the habit to eventually take you.

Marcus Sheridan's story is the clearest proof of that I know of in the marketing world, and it's a better case study than most business books because he wasn't trying to prove a theory when he lived it. He was trying to keep a pool company from going under.

The Question in Front of Him

In 2009, River Pools and Spas was close to bankruptcy. Sheridan didn't sit down and design a content marketing system. He sat at his kitchen table with a pencil and a sheet of paper and wrote down every question a customer had ever asked him, then started answering them, one at a time, on the company blog. No framework. No campaign calendar. No name for what he was doing. He was addressing the person standing in front of him, the way he'd always done in sales calls, except now he was doing it in writing, in public, every time a question came up.

One of those answers, "How Much Does a Fiberglass Pool Cost," took him about 45 minutes to write. It's since generated more than $35 million in revenue. He didn't know that when he wrote it. He couldn't have. It was one entry in a running habit of answering whatever question was in front of him that week, and it happened to be the one that landed.

Only after years of doing this did the habit get a name. "They Ask, You Answer" wasn't the plan Sheridan started with. It was the label he put on the pattern once he could see the shape of what he'd already been doing.

The Business Nobody Could Have Planned For

Here's where the story goes further than most personal-project cases. The pool business recovering was the first result, and it's the one you'd expect: better content, more trust, more sales. But the habit didn't stop there. Sheridan kept doing the same thing, answering the actual question in front of him, and eventually the thing in front of him wasn't a pool customer, it was another business owner asking how he'd done it. That question, answered the same way as all the others, turned into a second business: keynote speaking, coaching, and a marketing agency built entirely on teaching a habit he never set out to package.

Nobody plans for that outcome, because at the moment the habit starts, that outcome doesn't exist yet. It isn't on the roadmap. It can't be. The roadmap only has room for things you can already name.

Answering the Case for Planning First

There's a real, well-reasoned position on the other side of this. Allan Dib's The 1-Page Marketing Plan, also part of my own course list, argues that marketing works when you get specific before you start: who you're targeting, what you're offering, how you'll reach them. That's sound advice, and I don't want to pretend it isn't. A plan makes you clear about who you're for.

But a plan can only work with what you already know. It can tell you who your customer is today. It cannot plan for the version of your business that doesn't exist yet, because that version is built by the habit, not by the plan. Sheridan's plan in January 2009 was "answer questions and try not to go bankrupt." Nothing in that plan could have specified "in fifteen years, run a speaking and coaching company." The habit found that outcome. The plan never could have, because planning requires naming the destination, and the destination didn't have a name yet.

Do the Work You Can't See the Path For

This is the part I actually want business owners, photographers included, to sit with, because I watch this pattern constantly. People read the marketing books. They watch the YouTube breakdowns. They build the one-page plan, then a better one-page plan, then a content calendar to support the plan. All of that is useful, and none of it is the thing that produces a result. At some point the reading has to turn into publishing the post, answering the question, making the offer, doing the work, before there's any visible proof it's going to lead anywhere.

A lot of that hesitation isn't really about strategy. It's about not wanting to do something that might not work, dressed up as "still researching" or "still refining the plan." Sheridan's first blog posts were not good. He said so himself. He kept writing them anyway, because the habit wasn't conditional on the early results being impressive. The $35 million article and the second business were not visible from where he was standing in January 2009. They only exist because he did the work before there was a path he could see leading to them.

You will not be able to see the version of your business that a sustained habit is capable of producing. That is not a flaw in the habit. That is the entire reason the habit matters more than the plan. The plan can only work with what's already in front of you. The habit is what goes and finds the rest.

Sources and further reading

Articles Main Page